Création: 13 Octobre 2005.
Last update: 7 april 2006.
|
| |
|
|
|
|
IKHS - Indexing and Knowledge in Human Sciences
Work presentation road-map for the participants
We suggest a road-map so that all the participants present their own approach according to a similar structured way, that will provide guidelines to the workshop. All the participants should present their work according to this roadmap in a paper communication which should be :
In English
From 3 to 5 pages long
It should be sent before March 15th to
sylvie.calabretto at insa-lyon.fr
The paper format is available at http://www.sdc2006.org/proposition article.html
1) Short presentation of the approach :
Goal of the project from the point if view of a researcher in Human Sciences. Please try to situate your contribution in one of the following purposes :
1. To retrieve in documents the “knowledge” that scientists (in human sciences) mobilize in order to establish a result (reasoning underlying scientific results);
2. To study or edit the way a scientific makes use of sources to produce a result (research steps is considered here as an epistemological data to measure the result validity) ;
3. To share scientific sources and documents in order to stimulate the dynamic of research ;
4. To develop search tools to be applied on primary data
Handled data: raw data (primary sources) against sources modified for a better indexing (secondary sources)
If any software : functionalities, target users ;
2) Detailed presentation of the approach:
Nature of the models:
- Type of content;
- Data model;
- Degree of formalization;
- Ambition: to create some knowledge, to reach a consensus, to support dialogue between scientific streams, …
Nature of the documents:
- Factual descriptions versus reasoning (argumentative texts),
- Degree of structure of these texts : linear vs. structured, …
Way of designing the models:
- What are the used knowledge sources used? who is responsible for the model contents?
- What are the model life cycle? Is there any maintenance process?
What are the connexions between models and documents (indexing? annotation?) Who is setting these connexions and how? what is the purpose?
3) Methodological aspect, importance of cross-disciplinary research:
How was the approach defined?
What is the official position of human scientists concerning their data patrimony and their access to data?
How much does technology influence this position?
Is a cross-disciplinary research a major challenge to better study the question of the access to the content of documents? How can it be set?
4) Demonstrations, practical session to test and use the tools:
Protocol to use the tools and its results ;
Are the tools or frameworks providing an easier access to some resources or collections useful in the researchers’ activity in human sciences : data, knowledge and results about these data?
Are they forming new tools to be used by the researcher? How?
5) Comparison of the different approaches (models and tools) about one particular question:
what does each approach propose to represent knowledge about dating (periodisation)?
what does each approach propose when dealing with contradictory interpretations ?
|
|
| |
|
|
|